Rebranding an established local firm is tough.
Imagine it’s fraternity rush and you’re a hot prospect.
You’re smart, handsome, and athletic—you’re in demand and have received many solid offers. Which one will you accept? Most likely you’ll end up at the “best” fraternity―the one that seems to have the best people, the best reputation, and generates the most buzz.
Down the block, the no-name fraternities struggle to scrounge some of the leftovers, blaming a competitive market. They never hit the critical mass of size or renown. They should blame themselves instead, for not spinning or spreading their story. The best people want to be associated with the best organizations—whether it’s a fraternity or law firm.
One hundred law firms have moved into Chicago since the 1980s.
Most of these 100 regional and national firms have behaved like the nameless fraternities. Only a handful have made any impact whatsoever—or appear to have sincerely tried. And obviously, it’s not just Chicago; this same experience is occurring nationwide.
At Fishman Marketing, we’ve represented both acquiring and acquired law firms. We’ve noted why some mergers seem to succeed wildly, with the smaller acquired firms achieving significant local growth—while other new local offices founder, stagnate, or collapse.
What lessons can we take away from this?
How can the leaders of the new “branch” offices increase the chance that they’ll meet their aggressive growth targets?
Here are ten points, in two blog posts:
1. Great lawyers want to work at great law firms.
They want to be part of well-known firms with strong reputations. To attract the best laterals, you must be perceived as a platform where top lawyers can grow their practices.
If your satellite office hasn’t achieved its growth goals, consider whether your local merger-marketing was genuinely designed to ensure rapid success. Being a terrific firm isn’t enough unless your targets know it. Marketing should be Recruiting’s best friend, creating a sense of interest and excitement that makes the headhunters’ jobs easier.
(I know, I know, it’s not PC to call you a “branch” or “satellite” office―”every office is important, we’re all in this together, a rising tide…” yadda yadda yadda. You know the reality of your condition. Let’s speak plainly here.)
2. Your goal is to become one of your city’s 2-3 best-marketed firms.
You have 100+ local competitors all battling for dominance, seeking the best clients and laterals. Only a few can succeed. Your local marketing can’t be safe and conservative, it must be outstanding. You must stand far above 98% of the other firms. That’s a very big goal, and that’s probably not what your office’s marketing plan states or intends. It should, though. It can.
Dominance is achievable, but only if you (a) make that your clearly stated goal, and (b) have the marketing (i) budget and (ii) personnel who have done it before and can do it again. Very few law firms have the right marketing support for this unique type of initiative. Fewer still have those resources in any given local office. If you don’t have the skills in-house, then either bring in outside help, or accept that it’s never going to happen.
3. A branch office has different marketing needs.
It’s not that your firm-wide marketers are doing it wrong. but they are situated differently. Maintaining an existing brand requires different tools and techniques than building a brand-new one. They can afford to play it safer. They don’t need to rock the boat as much as you do. The current status quo works well for those in The Mothership. And the big-picture home-office marketers are focused on all of the firm’s offices. In marketing your local office, you’re mostly on your own.
You are getting bonused based upon the success of this one office.
You need to shake things up. Your office has become a brand-new local boutique law firm.
Stop acting like you’re part of a proud, prominent, well-known firm. Start thinking of yourself as a hungry start-up—a hot new firm no one has heard of yet.
Get mad that important prospects have never heard of your firm.
That will get you closer to the mindset that will help you succeed in your local market. Be hungry.
A start-up’s marketing must cost-effectively break through the clutter and shout your name loudly, clearly, and continuously. You must earn the visibility, not just go through the motions.
The firm may be the 800-pound gorilla in its home market―the biggest, oldest, baddest firm in Dallas, Des Moines, Dubuque, or Detroit―the firm that gets a first look at every major case, deal, and hot lateral recruit.
But in Chicago, no offense, your far-flung hometown reputation don’t mean squat.
We have 50+ more firms who look just like you, bragging about the “long, proud tradition” they built somewhere else. You’re just the latest in a long line of new kids who swaggered into town thinking they were going to come in and eat the local firms’ lunch. Most of those new branch offices stagnated at around 20 lawyers.
If you asked the average lawyer walking down LaSalle Street if they’d ever even heard of terrific firms like Akerman, Bryan Cave, Honigman, or Roetzel & Andress, I’d suggest that most lawyers won’t have—even though each firm is a leader in its home market. At best, they might dimly recognize the name if you mentioned it to them.
Or if you asked them what well-known Chicago law firms were acquired recently by Cozen O’Connor, Nixon Peabody, or Shook Hardy, I’ll bet you a dollar they couldn’t tell you. They’ll all remember Ungaretti & Harris (I was Marketing Partner there), but wouldn’t be able to tell you that they’re now called Nixon Peabody.
Remember, your audience won’t care about you unless you cause them to.
You must then remind them continuously and mercilessly over time, until they can’t possibly forget. That means powerful and effective creative strategy on the front end, launched with a marketing campaign that lasts long enough to really take hold. It sounds expensive to achieve this, but at Fishman Marketing, our budget goal is to design and launch this type of initiative for less than the cost of a single headhunter fee.
Don’t believe me?
Conduct some quick market research. The results should terrify you.
The awareness data will show you how far you have to go, how deep the hole your marketing must pull you out of. That research will help eliminate the current complacency, increase your budget, and spur action.
I’m not suggesting that you’re not a terrific firm with great lawyers and skilled marketers. My point is that major markets are harder to break into than most lawyers and marketers understand. This means that they don’t know how to plan, budget, or execute what it takes to show that they’re exceptional.
I still remember when Greenberg Traurig came into Chicago in the late 1990s. They started snapping up high-profile lawyers from prominent firms all over town. Every lawyer knew someone who had gotten hired away to make more money. There was buzz. People were asking “Who the hell is Greenberg Traurig???!” They wondered why they too hadn’t received a headhunter’s call. Greenberg didn’t creep into town; they blasted in with a parade and brass band. And their early success increased their long-term success.
4. If you’re a new or small office, you’re starting from scratch.
From absolute zero. If you have 75 or fewer lawyers, you can safely presume that barely a soul knows you unless they’ve physically sat on the other side of a counsel or negotiating table from you. Not only do they not know you, they don’t care about you either. Neither do the local law students.
This can be very difficult for most lawyers to accept, because their daily market research consists of an inherently tainted sample group. That is, everyone they interact with knows them. Or, as I like to say, “I have 100% market penetration in my house.” Literally everyone knows me there, so polling the extent of my market awareness doesn’t yield quantitatively valid data. I feel pretty well known.
You’re not nearly as well known as you think you are, whoever you are. I have 27 years’ marketing experience dealing with this issue; just trust me on this.
5. You’re not interesting unless you make yourself so.
You’re not memorable until you do something worth remembering. Marketing can do that for you, but it’s not accidental. It’s hard. And our audiences’ standards for what they’re willing to pay attention to keep rising.
They don’t have the time or attention span to invest in someone else’s boring marketing. Make it fabulous or they’re turning the page, averting their gaze, or clicking “Back.”
We’ll excitedly watch Super Bowl commercials because we have learned that they’ll be interesting, entertaining, unique, or helpful.
Very little law firm marketing is worth our prospects’ attention.
It should be. It can be. It just usually isn’t.
As an example, here’s a new-office print ad we designed for Florida’s Carlton Fields some years ago. Doesn’t it intrigue you and grab your attention? Consider how it compares to whatever your firm used. (More on that story next week.)